Average Payment Failed Email Benchmarks
Payment failure notification emails — commonly referred to as dunning emails — are sent when a customer's recurring payment fails due to an expired card, insufficient funds, or a processing error. These transactional emails achieve some of the highest engagement rates of any email type because they communicate critical account information that directly affects the recipient's access to a product or service they value. Average open rates for payment failure emails range from 50% to 70%, with click-through rates between 20% and 40%. The exceptional engagement reflects the high stakes involved: the recipient understands that failing to act will result in a disruption of service.
The payment recovery email sequence is typically structured as a series of three to five escalating communications. The initial notification alerts the customer to the failed payment and requests updated billing information. A second follow-up is sent 24–48 hours later if no action has been taken. Subsequent emails at increasing intervals escalate the urgency, culminating in a final notice before service suspension. Recovery rates for well-optimised dunning sequences range from 30% to 60%, meaning that a significant proportion of initially failed payments are successfully recovered through email communication alone. The timing, tone, and clarity of these emails are critical — overly aggressive messaging can damage customer relationships, while overly passive messaging may result in unnecessary churn.
Key Findings
- Payment failure notification emails achieve open rates of 50–70%, among the highest of any email campaign type.
- Click-through rates range from 20% to 40%, with the billing update link being the primary action.
- Well-structured dunning sequences recover 30–60% of initially failed payments through email alone.
- Each additional retry attempt in the sequence recovers 5–15% of remaining failed payments, with diminishing returns after 3–4 attempts.
- Clear, concise subject lines that directly state the issue — such as "Payment Failed: Update Your Billing Info" — outperform softer subject lines by 20–35%.
Open Rate Benchmarks
Open rates for payment failure emails are exceptionally high across the entire dunning sequence. The initial payment failure notification achieves open rates of 55–65%, as the recipient is immediately aware that an action is required. The first follow-up, sent 24–48 hours later, sees open rates of 50–60%. The second follow-up at 72–96 hours achieves 45–55%. The final notice before service suspension achieves the highest open rates at 60–75%, driven by the acute urgency of impending account suspension. Subject lines that clearly state the problem — "Payment Declined: Update Your Card" or "Action Required: Billing Issue" — consistently outperform vague or overly gentle subject lines. Including the specific date of the failed payment in the subject line can also improve open rates.
Click-Through Rate Benchmarks
Click-through rates for payment failure emails average 20–40%, significantly higher than most other email types due to the clear, singular action required. The initial notification email achieves CTR of 25–35% on the billing update link. The first follow-up sees CTR of 20–30%. The second follow-up achieves CTR of 15–25%. The final notice before suspension achieves CTR of 30–40%, as the urgency of impending service loss motivates last-minute action. Including a direct, one-click link to the billing update page — rather than requiring the user to log in and navigate to settings — can improve CTR by 30–50%. Mobile optimisation is also critical, as many users will attempt to resolve billing issues directly from their phone.
Best Practices
- Send the first payment failure notification immediately after the failed attempt, with subsequent follow-ups at 24, 72, and 168 hours if no action is taken.
- Use clear, direct subject lines that state the problem without causing unnecessary alarm — "Payment Failed: Update Your Billing Information."
- Provide a direct, one-click link to the billing update page to minimise friction and maximise recovery rates.
- Include information about what was being paid for and the service amount to provide context for the recipient.
- Offer multiple payment method options — card, PayPal, direct debit — to increase the likelihood of successful recovery.
- Send a final notice before service suspension with clear information about what will happen if no action is taken and how to prevent disruption.
Related Benchmarks
Abandoned Checkout — Email Marketing Benchmarks
Abandoned checkout email benchmarks for recovering customers who started checkout. Open rates 35-50%, CTR 12-25%, recovery rates 8-20%.
Account Recovery — Email Marketing Benchmarks
Email marketing benchmarks for account recovery and re-activation emails including dormant account recovery, password reset, and re-engagement campaign performance data.
Account Verification & Confirmation Email Benchmarks
Email marketing benchmarks for account verification and confirmation emails. Open rates 40-65%, CTR 20-40%, verification completion rates, re-verification, MFA notification, and security alert data.
Annual Report — Email Marketing Benchmarks
Email marketing benchmarks for annual report distribution and shareholder communications including engagement rates, compliance requirements, and best practices.
Back-in-Stock Notification Email Benchmarks
Email marketing benchmarks for back-in-stock notification campaigns. Open rates 30-50%, CTR 15-35%, waiting list conversion, restock alerts, exclusive early access, and sell-through rate data.
Backorder Notification — Email Marketing Benchmarks
Backorder and pre-order status update email benchmarks for notifying customers about item availability. Open rates 35-55%, CTR 15-30%.
Frequently Asked Questions
A good open rate for payment failure emails ranges from 55% to 70%, with the initial notification and final suspension notice achieving the highest rates. Rates below 40% suggest deliverability issues or subject lines that are not clearly communicating the urgency of the message.
The optimal dunning sequence typically includes three to five emails. The first sent immediately after the failure, the second at 24–48 hours, the third at 72–96 hours, and a final notice before service suspension. Each additional email recovers 5–15% of remaining failed payments, though recovery diminishes after 3–4 attempts.
The best subject lines are clear, direct, and state the problem explicitly. "Payment Failed: Update Your Billing Info" or "Action Required: Your Payment Was Declined" consistently outperform softer approaches. Including the date of the failed payment or the service name can further improve open rates.
Improving recovery rates requires a well-timed sequence of clear, action-oriented emails with minimal friction. Providing a direct one-click link to the billing update page is the single most effective tactic. Offering multiple payment methods and sending a final urgency-driven notice before suspension also significantly improve recovery.
Yes, including customer support contact information is strongly recommended. Some payment failures result from genuine issues the customer needs help resolving — such as a new card that has not arrived or a banking error. Providing support contact details in the email reduces frustration and can help recover payments that a purely automated sequence would miss.