Average Insurance Industry Email Benchmarks
Insurance email marketing spans auto, home, life, health, and commercial lines. Engagement varies significantly by policy type and the stage of the customer lifecycle. Renewal reminders and policy documents achieve high open rates due to their transactional nature, while cross-sell and brand-building campaigns see more moderate engagement. Insurance is a considered purchase, so the path from email click to quote takes longer than in retail or e-commerce.
| Metric | Average | Above Average | Excellent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open Rate | 18-22% | 24%+ | 28%+ |
| Click-Through Rate | 1.5-3.5% | 4%+ | 5.5%+ |
| Click-to-Open Rate | 10-14% | 15%+ | 19%+ |
| Conversion Rate (Quote) | 1-2% | 2.5%+ | 4%+ |
| Bounce Rate | 1.5-3% | Below 1% | Below 0.5% |
| Unsubscribe Rate | 0.2% | Below 0.12% | Below 0.08% |
| Spam Complaint Rate | 0.05% | Below 0.03% | Below 0.01% |
Key Findings
- Renewal reminder emails achieve open rates of 35-50%, significantly higher than the industry average, because they contain critical policy information.
- Cross-sell campaigns (home insurance to auto insurance customers) see CTRs of 1.5-3%, with conversion rates of 1-2% when properly targeted.
- Life insurance email campaigns average lower open rates (16-20%) but higher click-to-open rates (14-18%) due to the considered nature of the purchase.
- Health insurance open season campaigns see a 25-35% spike in engagement during enrolment windows.
- Personalised quote emails with specific premium amounts achieve 40-50% higher CTR than generic rate promotion emails.
Open Rate Benchmarks
Insurance open rates average 18-22%, placing the industry in the mid-range compared to other sectors. Transactional emails like policy documents, billing notifications, and renewal reminders drive the highest open rates at 35-50%. Educational content about coverage types and risk management achieves 20-25% open rates, while promotional rate emails average 15-18%. The insurance industry faces strict spam filter regulations, which can impact deliverability if emails are not properly authenticated.
Click-Through Rate Benchmarks
CTR in the insurance sector averages 1.5-3.5%. Renewal reminder emails with a clear call to action (e.g. "Get Your Renewal Quote") achieve 4-6% CTR. Cross-sell campaigns average 1.5-3%, and educational content about policy features typically sees 2-4%. The best-performing insurance emails use personalised premium estimates and clear policy benefit summaries rather than generic insurance messaging.
Best Practices
- Automate renewal sequences: Send renewal reminders at 60, 30, and 7 days before expiry. These automated emails achieve 35-50% open rates and reduce policy lapse rates by 15-25%.
- Segment by policy type: Auto, home, life, and health customers have very different needs. Segmentation by policy type improves CTR by 25-35% compared to cross-segment blasts.
- Use social proof: Include customer testimonials and Trustpilot-style ratings in insurance emails. Emails featuring social proof see 20-30% higher conversion rates.
- Simplify the quote process: Emails linking directly to pre-filled quote forms with known customer details convert at 2-3x the rate of emails requiring fresh data entry.
- Leverage life events: Marriages, new homes, and new children are key trigger events for insurance needs. Email campaigns triggered by life events achieve 3-4x higher conversion rates.
- Maintain GDPR and CAN-SPAM compliance: Insurance data is highly sensitive. Ensure double opt-in processes, clear privacy policies, and easy unsubscribe options are in place.
Related Benchmarks
Account Creation Email Benchmarks
Account creation confirmation email benchmarks for open rates, click-through rates, and activation rates. Account creation emails confirm successful registration and guide users to their first action.
Account Deletion Email Benchmarks
Account deletion email benchmarks for open rates, click-through rates, and recovery rates. Account deletion emails confirm account closure and offer a final opportunity to recover the account.
Account Verification & Confirmation Email Benchmarks
Email marketing benchmarks for account verification and confirmation emails. Open rates 40-65%, CTR 20-40%, verification completion rates, re-verification, MFA notification, and security alert data.
Industry — Accounting Bookkeeping Email Marketing Benchmarks
Email marketing benchmarks for accounting, tax and bookkeeping firms covering tax season campaigns, client retention nurture and financial advisory content. Open rates 22-30%, CTR 2-5%.
Activewear Email Marketing Benchmarks
Email marketing benchmarks for activewear and athleisure brands including open rates, click rates and strategies for community, launches and lifestyle content.
Activity Digest Email Benchmarks
Activity digest email benchmarks for open rates, click-through rates, and engagement rates. Digest emails summarise recent activity, news, or content in a regular roundup format.
Frequently Asked Questions
The average open rate for insurance email marketing is 18-22%. Renewal reminder and billing notification emails perform significantly better at 35-50%, while promotional and cross-sell campaigns average 15-18%.
A good CTR for insurance emails is 1.5-3.5%. Policy renewal links and personalised quote CTAs achieve 4-6%, while educational content about coverage types averages 2-4%.
Cross-sell email campaigns in insurance achieve CTRs of 1.5-3% and conversion rates of 1-2%. Best results come from targeting existing customers with complementary policies shortly after their initial purchase.
Renewal reminders and policy documents perform best with 35-50% open rates. Educational content about risk management and coverage gaps also performs well. Promotional rate emails have the lowest engagement.
Insurers should implement DMARC, DKIM, and SPF authentication, maintain a clean list by removing hard bounces and inactive subscribers, use double opt-in for new subscribers, and avoid spam trigger words like "free quote" and "guaranteed savings" in subject lines.