Why Email Open Rate Is a Misleading Metric (And What to Track Instead)

For decades, email open rate has been the go-to metric for measuring campaign success. Walk into any marketing meeting and someone will inevitably ask: "What was the open rate?"

But here's the uncomfortable truth: open rate has become one of the least reliable metrics in your email analytics dashboard.

Changes in privacy technology, inconsistent tracking methods, and fundamental measurement flaws mean that open rate often tells you more about technical behavior than actual human engagement.

In this post, we'll break down exactly why open rate misleads marketers, what's changed in recent years, and why smart email strategists are moving beyond it as a primary success indicator.

The Fundamental Problem With How Opens Are Tracked

Before we dive into modern privacy issues, let's address the core tracking flaw that's existed since email marketing began.

An "open" isn't tracked by detecting when someone reads your email. Instead, it's measured by a 1×1 pixel image (tracking pixel) embedded in the email. When that pixel loads, it fires back to the sender: "This email was opened."

The Problem?

Loading an image ≠ Reading content

Someone could:

Open your email and immediately archive it (tracked as "opened")
Have their email client automatically load images without them seeing it (tracked as "opened")
Read your entire email in preview mode with images blocked (tracked as "not opened")

This tracking method has always been imperfect — but recent changes have made it dramatically worse.

The Apple Mail Privacy Protection Bombshell

In September 2021, Apple dropped a bomb on email marketers: Mail Privacy Protection (MPP).

Here's what it does:

When MPP is enabled (and millions of users have enabled it), Apple's servers pre-fetch and cache all images in emails — including tracking pixels — before the user even sees the email.

What This Means For Your Metrics

Your email gets counted as "opened" the moment it arrives, whether the recipient:

Actually opens it
Reads it
Even sees it in their inbox

Many marketers saw their open rates jump 10-30% overnight when MPP rolled out. But this wasn't because their emails suddenly got better — it's because robot servers started registering as "opens".

The Scale of The Problem

According to Litmus, approximately 50% of email opens now come from Apple Mail Privacy Protection users. That means half your "opens" might not represent real human behavior at all.

Email Client Fragmentation Makes It Worse

Even without Apple's privacy features, email client behavior varies wildly:

Email Client	Default Tracking Behavior
Apple Mail (MPP on)	Auto-loads images immediately
Gmail	Caches images on Google servers
Outlook Desktop	Blocks images by default
Yahoo Mail	Loads images by default
Outlook.com	Blocks images in some configurations

The result? The same email sent to the same person can show completely different open tracking results depending purely on which app they use to check email that day.

This isn't measuring engagement — it's measuring email client configuration.

What Open Rate Actually Tells You (And Doesn't)

Let's be clear about what open rate can and cannot measure:

✅ Open Rate CAN Tell You:

Approximate delivery success (if it's extremely low)
Very broad trends over time within the same audience
Whether a dramatic subject line change had some effect

❌ Open Rate CANNOT Tell You:

Whether anyone actually read your email
Whether your content resonated
Whether recipients found value
Who is genuinely engaged vs. passively receiving
Accurate performance for Apple Mail users (50%+ of opens)

The Dangerous Psychology of Over-Relying On Opens

Beyond technical limitations, open rate creates a psychological trap for marketers.

The "Vanity Metric" Problem

Open rate is easy to improve artificially:

Use clickbait subject lines
Send more frequently to inflate "unique opens"
Email during off-hours when MPP is more likely to auto-load

But none of these tactics improve actual business results.

It Rewards The Wrong Behavior

When teams obsess over open rate, they optimize for:

Subject line tricks instead of content quality
Sending more emails instead of better emails
Broad audiences instead of engaged segments

Real engagement metrics (clicks, conversions, revenue) often move in the opposite direction.

What You Should Track Instead

If open rate is unreliable, what should you focus on?

1. Click-Through Rate (CTR)

Clicks ÷ Delivered emails

Unlike opens, clicks require conscious action. No email client can "auto-click" for users. This measures real engagement.

2. Click-to-Open Rate (CTOR)

Clicks ÷ Opens

For those who did open (however that's tracked), did they take action? High opens with low CTOR means your subject line overpromises or your content underdelivers.

3. Conversion Rate

Goal completions ÷ Delivered (or Clicks)

The ultimate metric: did the email drive business results? Purchases, signups, downloads — whatever your goal is.

4. List Health Metrics

Unsubscribe rate
Spam complaint rate
Hard bounce rate

These show whether you're maintaining list quality and trust.

5. Revenue Per Email

Total revenue generated ÷ Emails delivered

For ecommerce and SaaS, this cuts through all the noise and asks: did this make money?

A Better Way to Interpret Email Performance

Here's how to read your metrics when open rate is unreliable:

Scenario 1: High Opens, Low Clicks

What it means: Your subject line is working (or MPP is inflating numbers), but your email content isn't compelling enough to drive action.

What to do: Focus on your email copy, CTA placement, and content relevance — not your subject line.

Scenario 2: Low Opens, High Click-to-Open Rate

What it means: The people who do engage are highly interested. You might have deliverability issues or your subject lines aren't reaching the right segment.

What to do: Check spam folder placement, review list segmentation, and test subject line clarity (not clickbait).

Scenario 3: Opens Spiked But Nothing Else Changed

What it means: Likely MPP or email client changes — not actual behavior change.

What to do: Don't celebrate yet. Check if clicks, conversions, or revenue moved. If not, it's a tracking artifact.

Using Tools to See the Whole Picture

Instead of relying on open rate as a standalone number, tools like Email Calculator help you combine the key metrics into a clear, fast view of campaign health — so you can ask better questions like:

Is this campaign actually performing?
How does it compare to past campaigns?
Where should I focus my optimisation efforts?

Summary

Open rate will never disappear as a metric — but taken alone it can often mislead:

Apple Mail Privacy Protection can inflate numbers
Email clients track opens inconsistently
Opens don’t show engagement or behaviour

That’s why the best marketers look at open rate in context — with clicks, conversions, and overall engagement metrics.

The Bottom Line: Stop Making Decisions Based On Opens Alone

Open rate isn't going away. ESPs will keep reporting it. Stakeholders will keep asking about it.

But smart marketers treat it as context, not gospel.

Instead of asking "What was the open rate?", start asking:

What was the click-through rate?
Did we drive conversions?
Is our list health improving or declining?
What's the revenue impact?

These questions lead to better decisions — and better email marketing.

Track What Actually Matters

Open rate was a useful proxy metric when it was all we had. But in 2026, with privacy protections, client fragmentation, and better analytics available, it's time to move on.

Tools like Email Calculator help you focus on metrics that actually correlate with business results — clicks, conversions, and ROI — so you can make decisions based on real engagement, not tracking pixel artifacts.

Want to quickly sanity-check your email campaign performance? Try our Email Calculator

Related Guides: